Archive for April, 2008

The sexist, the violent and the racist: The most complained about adverts of last year

30th April 2008
Sex sells when it comes to advertising, but that doesn’t mean customers are particularly happy about it.

In fact, the sensitive masses complained about more adverts than ever before on the grounds they were violent, racist, sexist or showed gratuitous sexual images.

A growing irritation among potential customers has been firms who make over the top claims about their “green” credentials.

Scroll down for more …

Smoking advertDistressing: This advert warning about the dangers of smoking received more complaints than any other

These prompted a surge of complaints to advertising watchdogs, according to a new report.

There a total of 24,192 complaints to the Advertising Standards Authority last years – an increase of 7.9 per cent from 2006.

A Department of Health anti-smoking campaign showing people with fish-hooks in their mouths was the most complained about advert of the year.

It drew 774 objections from viewers and readers who found them offensive, frightening and distressing.

Scroll down for more …

BHF adRude: This advert for the British Heart Foundation caused some upset

The top 10 most complained about adverts, which included MFI and Quorn, sparked fury over themes of violence, sex and race.

Violent imagery appeared in two of the most complained-about ads other than the DoH fish-hook campaign.

An MFI television ad showed a woman slapping her husband while a TV ad for Quorn included a teenager threatening her brother with a fork.

A Cadbury TV ad for Trident chewing gum drew complaints that it stereotyped and ridiculed black people, while another by Kepak UK showing a woman in her underwear on a rotating sofa attracted objections that it was offensive, sexist and demeaning to women.

Scroll down for more …

Trident chewing gumRacist: An advert for Trident chewing gum was the said to promote negative stereotypes

Misleading ads accounted for nearly half of all complaints, while offensiveness was the main reason for complaints about broadcast advertising.

Anger over green claims shot up by over 50 per cent from 2006 to 556 objections about 408 ads as advertisers try to cash in on the environment.

Household names such as Ryanair, easyJet, Npower, Citroen and Shell all fell foul of advertising rules over claims about the environment.

Airlines were criticised for claims about C02 emissions as were car manafacturers.

Conservative MP John Whittingdale, chair of culture, media and sport select committee said of the green claims: “Plainly the reason they are doing it is because they believe that they need to demonstrate this. But if they are going to make claims they have to make sure they are correct.”

The ASA also said in its annual report, released yesterday, that a record 2,458 ads were changed or withdrawn last year.

The number of ads drawing objections shot up by almost 10 per cent last year.

TV was the main culprit being the cause of 9,915 complaints, followed by internet advertising at 2,980 objections.

The internet was particularly singled out by the public over pricing, availability of goods and charges.

ASA chairman Lord Smith said the year had been the authority’s busiest ever and warned that the rising number of complaints about internet content posed a challenge to self-regulation.

The ASA is the independent watchdog for UK advertising. It is funded via a levy charged to advertisers.

Its remit includes paid-for online adverts and “viral” internet adverts but excludes promotions on companies’ own websites which are considered to be editorial.

• The top five

1. ‘Fish hook’ anti-smoking campaign.

• 774 complaints raising objections that it was offensive, frightening and distressing.

2. Trident chewing gum

• 519 complaints objecting to racial stereotypes in the advert.

3. Rustlers burgers and chicken naan

• 219 complaints stating that is was offensive, sexist and demeaning to women.

4. ‘You’ll feel right at home’ MFI advert

• 217 complaints over violence

5. Quorn

• 181 complaints that the advert showed scenes of violence (not upheld)

Teens convicted of terrifying petrol attack

Exclusive By A J Sicluna

Sajid Ali
Sajid Ali

TWO youths were locked up after they were convicted of kidnapping a teenager, dousing him with petrol and threatening to set him alight.

Newport teens Salman Ullah, 17, and Sajid Ali, 17, were both given detention and training orders after they subjected their 16-year-old victim to, what a judge called, a “frightening and humiliating” ordeal.

The victim was “enticed” to a house in Newport, tied up, taken to a nearby derelict garage, attacked with a baseball bat and doused in petrol after which a lighter was flicked in front of him.

Ullah, an international amateur boxer, of high Cross Lane, Rogerstone, was sentenced to a detention and training order for two years at Cardiff Crown Court.

Ali, of Eton Road, Newport, was handed an 18-month detention and training order.

Both were found guilty of kidnapping, making threats to kill, and stealing the boy’s mobile phone.

A 14-year-old youth, who was a member of the gang, received a three year supervision order after his conviction for kidnapping and making threats to kill.

He was also ordered to observe a six month curfew from 7pm to 6am and to be electronically tagged.

Salman Ullah
Salman Ullah

Prosecutor Michael Mather Lees said the three took part in a premeditated plan after Ullah’s girlfriend had formed an association with the victim, something Ullah didn’t like.

He was lured to a house in Newport, where there was allegedly a party, before his ordeal began.

At one point he was told he was going to be taken to a cemetery where he would die.

During the ordeal Ullah repeatedly shouted at the petrified man “how far have you gone with her?”

He was also told that he would be killed if he told anyone what had happened. The three denied being involved.

Judge William Gaskell, who lifted an order which had prevented Ullah and Ali being identified, told Ullah: “You could not take it that your girlfriend dumped you and you decided to take revenge on the victim, frightening and humiliating him. You were the instigator of the offences.”

Tracey Lloyd-Nesling, for Ullah, said he was a youth of previous good behaviour.

“He is remorseful and these proceedings have made an impact upon him,” she added.

Claire Pickthall, for Ali had learned a significant lesson.

Nicholas Gareth Jones, for the 14-year-old, said his involvement was very much out of character.

10:30am Thursday 24th April 2008

Prisoners should earn pay rise, says Brown

By Andrew Woodcock, PA
Wednesday, 30 April 2008

Gordon Brown confirmed today that he personally intervened to block plans to increase prisoners’ pay rates by 37.5 per cent – their first rise for more than a decade.

The Prime Minister said any changes in pay should come as part of a new contract being drawn up which will reward inmates for good behaviour behind bars and participation in programmes designed to prevent reoffending, such as drug treatment.

The Prime Minister overruled proposals put to him yesterday by the Prison Service Management Board to increase the minimum pay rate for an offender working inside a jail from £4 a week to £5.50 a week.

The minimum rate for prisoners who are ill or deemed unemployed because there is not anything for them to do was also set to go up, from £2.50 to £4, a rise of 60 per cent.

The announcement that the proposed increase was being blocked came days after the deputy general secretary of the Prison Officers Association, Glyn Travis, claimed life was so “cushy” in Britain’s jails that inmates were passing up chances to escape.

The Ministry of Justice said today that the new rates had been withdrawn and were now part of a ministerial review.

An MoJ spokesman said: “The issue as to whether pay rates should be increased is now being reviewed as part of (Prison Minister) David Hanson’s proposals for a new compact balancing the opportunities we give to offenders to turn away from a life of crime with what the community is going to expect of them in return.

“That means meeting certain standards of behaviour whilst in prison and on release, for instance getting off and staying off drugs.”

Speaking on the BBC Radio 4 Today programme, Mr Brown explained: “To be absolutely clear, the proposal came to me yesterday that we wanted to announce that we raise the wages of prisoners.

“We are now debating a contract with prisoners so they are better behaved…

“I think any debate about what prisoners receive in pay should be part of that new contract.

“There should be rights, but there should be responsibilities, and it’s the responsibilities of prisoners that I am interested in.”

The Prison Service operates a range of restrictions on inmates’ finances and they are not allowed to hold cash for security reasons. Money earned can be spent on expenses like phone calls, renting a TV or buying treats from the canteen.

The Prison Service’s internet site says work can play a “fundamental role” in providing skills and qualifications that help inmates get a job once they are released.

Jobs vary between jails but can include catering, cleaning, data entry, component assembly and even computer-aided design.

Juliet Lyon, of the Prison Reform Trust, told Today: “If we are serious about encouraging people to lead a responsible life on release and to work constructively, then clearly it’s not much to ask that they get another pound a week.

“We are talking about £4 a week, going up to £5.50 a week, out of which prisoners have to pay for all their phone calls at an exorbitant rate… they have often to rent a TV and they have to buy a few bits and pieces from the canteen if they can afford it.

“We are talking about pence here, nothing substantial, but this hasn’t changed for 10 years.”

She blamed “muscle flexing” by prison officer union chiefs engaged in a leadership battle for stoking media reports that prisoners enjoyed easy conditions.

“Staff have a right to feel they are really under pressure but, unfortunately, using these sort of headline-grabbing techniques may have led everybody to believe this fantasy that people are having a very cushy life.

“If you look at the level of self-harm or suicide, it completely blows away the idea that this is cushy and it shows you just how very tough it is,” she said.

Labour MP Nick Palmer, a member of the Home Affairs Select Committee, said it would not be right to make a “special case” for prisoners at a time of pay restraint for public sector workers.

“We are asking nurses, police officers and prison staff and teachers all to accept pay rises of 2 per cent-3 per cent; I do not think we can sensibly or even reasonably say prisoners should get a pay rise of 38%.”

Ms Lyon later accused the Government of “penny-pinching”.

She said: “Constructive work in prisons, housing and employment on release and contact with families are the things that cut reoffending.

“Overturning the decision to raise prisoners’ pay for the first time in 10 years is not only penny-pinching but also short-sighted.

“Many prisoners would have spent the extra £1.50 on a phone card to ring home or try to sort out accommodation or a job.”

Daughter’s nightmare of mother falling out of cupboard led police to her body

By TOM KELLY -  29th April 2008

A former civil servant bludgeoned his wife to death with a mallet and stored her body in a box in the garden, a court heard yesterday.

Catherine Genestin, 38, was eventually discovered after her young daughter had a nightmare about her body falling out of a cupboard, and raised the alarm with teachers.

The child had been in bed when she overheard her mother and father, Andre, 48, having a blazing row.

Mrs Genestin had learnt that her husband had an internet lover, a female Ukrainian student whom he was helping to get a UK visa.

Andre Genestin leaves court today. He is charged with murdering his wife after she discovered about his internet lover

He smashed his wife’s skull with a mallet as she sat on the sofa in their semi-detached house in Brighton last May, Lewes Crown Court heard.

Genestin stored her body in an understairs cupboard before moving it to a car roof box in the back garden.

He spun a ‘web of lies’ to conceal his wife’s disappearance, claiming she had run off with an Italian lover and sending emails from her account to friends, Christine Laing QC told the jury.

She said: ‘The first person to doubt his account was his daughter. She had heard her mum and dad arguing and when she got up the next day her mum was not there.

‘She did all she could to get other adults to look into the situation, speaking to her teachers to get them to do something.’

When her class teacher failed to take action, she invented a story that she was being bullied to get the headmistress’s attention.

Catherine Genestin with her husband Andre who killed her with a hammer

The head told social services and the following month police found Mrs Genestin’s body in the box her husband had bought days after her death.

The daughter, who cannot be named for legal reasons, later told police she had gone into the cupboard where her mother was initially kept about two weeks after she went missing because she thought there would be a body in there.

Miss Laing said: ‘She spoke of a dream about opening a cupboard door and her mum’s body falling out.

‘She thought her mum must be dead because otherwise she would have been missing her and would have come back for her.’

Before the body was found, the court heard, neighbours had climbed over the fence to investigate the ‘horrendous’ smell coming from the box, which had flies swarming around it, but they were unable to open it.

One neighbour saw Genestin scooping liquid oozing from the box into a mug and polishing the sides with a rag.

Officers who broke into the casket discovered the body wrapped in plastic bags and a tarpaulin. They also found books in his house giving advice on how to remove traces of blood and fingerprints, as well as tactics for answering police questions.

The couple were both French nationals but moved to Britain soon after they married.

They were regular churchgoers and Genestin had spoken to a pastor about the possibility of becoming a minister shortly before his wife’s death.

He is believed to have worked as a civil servant but was unemployed when he was arrested. He is said to have boasted to friends about his ‘dodgy dealings’ and benefit fraud.

His wife was a receptionist at a gym and was applying to be a classroom assistant.

Genestin admits killing his wife but denies murder. He said he did not intend to kill her or cause her serious bodily harm.

He said that he was provoked by her behaviour and reacted in a way that any reasonable person would do in such a situation.

The trial continues.

British Muslim ‘bullied’ for becoming a Christian

By Bonnie Malkin  29/04/2008

A British man who was attacked after converting to Christianity from Islam was told by police to “move to another place”, it has emerged.

Nissar Hussein, 43, from Bradford, West Yorkshire converted from Islam to Christianity with his wife, Qubra, in 1996.

A report by Christian Solidarity Worldwide, quoted in the Times, says he was subjected to a number of attacks and, after being told that his house would be burnt down if he did not return to Islam, alerted the police.

However, the report says Mr Hussein was told that such threats were rarely carried out and that he should “stop being a crusader and move to another place”.

A few days later an unoccupied property next door to Mr Hussein’s house was set on fire.

The report, titled No Place to Call Home, claims that apostates from Islam are subject to “gross and wide-ranging human rights abuses”.

“When identities are precarious, their enforcement will take an aggressive form.”

Teenager beaten in park attack

By Steve Wright

David Procter after the attack
David Procter after the attack

A mother today condemned young thugs who robbed and beat her teenage son and left him naked in a park.

David Procter, 16, was forced to strip and hand over jewellery and his mobile phone, before being viciously punched and kicked in the head and body.

His three attackers also set two dogs on him and he was bitten on the ear.

The youngster, who suffers from asthma, was left with serious facial injuries, including a broken nose, fractured cheekbone and broken teeth.

A passing motorist draped a blanket around him and took him to Bradford Royal Infirmary for treatment.

Detectives are investigating the “unusual” incident.

David’s mother, Julie Procter, said she could not believe what the attackers had done to her son when she saw his injuries in hospital.She said: “It was bad enough David being beaten up and robbed, but then to take all his clothes and leave him there was beyond belief. All they left him with was a little eye stud.”

He had been treated at BRI for chest pains brought on by his asthma and had set off to walk to his father’s home in Holme Wood when the attack happened, at around 1am last Sunday (April 20).

David said: “I was at the entrance to Lister Park. I saw a young Asian lad and asked him for directions. He whistled two others over and they offered to take me in a car. I thought something was a bit dodgy and I said I would walk. When I turned to go they started on me.”

The teenager said he was forced to hand over his mobile phone and items of jewellery.

He was then made to strip off all his clothes.

But when he tried to hand over a gold chain he had to rip it from his neck to get it free.

“One of them said: I wanted it all together’ and they started beating me up,” said David. “One lad punched me twice in the face, knocking me to the ground. All three then just started kicking me in the side and the face.

“I was covering my face up. I was frightened and in pain. Then they set the dogs on me. I just wanted it to end and to go home. They didn’t say anything while they were beating me. Then they just walked off and left me on the ground.”

He added: “They need locking up. If it has happened to me, it will happen to somebody else. One of the nurses told me it happens quite often in that area.”

Police took David back to the park so he could identify the place the attack happened. He has also given a statement and had his injuries photographed.

Detective Inspector Gerry O’Shea, of Bradford South CID, said it was a highly unusual type of crime.

“The stealing of the clothes is quite bizarre and using dogs in the crime is unusual in itself.

“It is being actively investigated and we are looking at a number of inquiries, which includes checking CCTV in the park.

“We urge anyone with information to contact the investigating officer, PC Louise Matthews, of Bradford South Police, on 0845 6060606, or Crimestoppers, anonymously, on 0800 555 111.”

One of the robbers was aged 16 or 17, slim, 5ft 9ins tall, with short dark hair and spoke with an English/Asian accent. Another was aged about 17 and 5ft 9ins tall. The third suspect was about 18, slightly taller than the others, slim, spoke with an English/Asian accent and wore an orange and black horizontally-striped jumper. He had the two Staffordshire Bull Terrier-type dogs on leads.

Mrs Procter said: “I want to thank the person who took David to hospital. These thugs had beaten him black and blue and left him without a stitch of clothing.”

6:12am Friday 25th April 2008

19 year old man chased down and attacked by gang of 15

Apr 28 2008 by Andrew Hirst, Huddersfield Daily Examiner

A 15-STRONG gang attacked a young man after chasing him for almost half-a-mile.

The 19-year-old was walking down Manchester Road, Thornton Lodge, at 9.30pm on Saturday to meet his girlfriend when he saw the gang standing on a grass verge on St Thomas’ Road.

They started to chase him and he fled along Manchester Road and then up steps next to St Thomas’ Church at Longroyd Bridge to Water Street in Springwood.

The gang cornered him in a garden there and beat him with baseball bats and pieces of wood.

He was left badly bruised and needed treatment at Huddersfield Royal Infirmary.

Det Con Russ Conlon, from Kirklees CID intelligence unit, said: “This was a motiveless attack.

“We would urge anyone who saw this gang hanging around, chasing the victim or the attack itself to come forward.’’

All the attackers are young Asian men and there were about 15 of them.

The ringleader is aged about 20, 5ft 8in tall and slim.

He wore a plain grey hooded top.

Too fat to toddle: How plump kids are transformed at fat camp

By NATASHA COURTENAY-SMITH -  29th April 2008
At just seven years old, Shane Holleywell already weighed almost 10st. His Body Mass Index (BMI) was a staggering 36.9, double what it should be, making him morbidly obese; the only clothes that would fit him were for children five years older.

His weight severely affected his mobility. The sheer effort of walking up the two flights of stairs to the family’s flat left him in tears.

Scroll down for more…

Teighan Robertson before fat camp, weighing six stone

Shane has been hugely overweight for years, and on one occasion, aged nearly three, had to be admitted to hospital as an emergency after he turned blue in his sleep: his body weight was crushing his airways and suffocating him.

By the time Teighan Robertson was one, she was already too heavy for her mother to lift. Four years later she was wearing clothes meant for a 12-yearold, she weighed 6st 2lb and her BMI was 27.

As with Shane, the slightest physical activity was too much. At an age when her contemporaries were learning to ride a bike, the five-year-old would have to lean against the gate to catch her breath even after a short run down the garden path.

Theirs are horrifyingly common stories. Around four-and-a-half million children in the UK are overweight or obese, and the problem is growing.

More pre-school children than ever — a quarter of them — fall into these two categories. And the worry is that once obese, they will remain so, with serious implications for their health.

“Eight out of ten obese children will become obese adults,” says Professor Paul Gately, director of Carnegie Weight Management at Leeds Metropolitan University.

Not only does this expose them to problems suchas bullying, but it puts them at greater risk of premature death through conditions such as diabetes, heart disease and cancer.

How is it that parents can let their children get so big?

Weight for me! Teighan with mum Sonia after losing almost 11⁄2st

Professor Gately says most parents are in denial about the real cause of the problem — that they are to blame.

“They come to me with all sorts of reasons as to why their child is overweight, such as a slow metabolism or the idea that being overweight is in the family genes,” he says.

“But this isn’t the problem.

“The fact is that parents are confused by food — they hear all the messages about fats, sugar and salt being bad, and they feel overwhelmed.

“They are often unable to read food labels properly — simply because they haven’t been shown how to.

“Really, the only thing they need to worry about is calories. It’s a simple equation of energy in versus energy out. If we eat too much and exercise too little, we become overweight.”

Not only do parents overestimate how many calories their child needs but, he says, they also usefood — particularly sweets, chocolates and crisps — “to show their children love and control their behaviour”.

“Childhood obesity is on the rise, largely because children are increasingly sedentary and parents are uneducated about diet. While help is available for older children, there has been little intervention for pre-school children.

“The more we can nip pre-school obesity in the bud, the more successful we’ll be at tackling later-childhood and adult obesity.”

To this end, Professor Gately has just run Britain’s first weight loss camp for children under eight (he’s run similar programmes for teenagers for the past eight years).

At the camp, which features in the ITV documentary Too Fat To Toddle next Tuesday, he helped parents tackle their misapprehensions and offered common-sense advice — with startling results.

Not only did the children involved in the programme lose significant amounts of weight, but in research to be published tomorrow in the Journal Of Atherosclerosis And Thrombosis, their levels of LDL — the “bad” cholesterol linked to heart disease — also dropped. SHANE and Teighan were among the first attendees at the camp and, six weeks later, both of them have lost a significant amount of weight.

But not without their mothers having to face up to some painful truths.

“Because I’ve always been a size eight, and my two other children are slim, I assumed Teighan had some sort of genetic condition that was causing her weight gain,” says her mother, 32-yearold Sonia Robertson from Tullibody, in Clackmannanshire, Scotland.

In fact, it emerged that Teighan was consuming a massive 2,680 calories a day — 600 more than an adult woman should eat, and more than twice what a child of her age should have.

An average three-year-old needs around 1,100 calories a day; an average five-year-old needs 1,200 calories; and an average seven-year-old 1,400 to 1,500. “As a baby, when Teighan cried I’d feed her,” says Sonia.

“I hadn’t even realised you could over-feed a baby or a small child; I thought they stopped eating when they were full.

“Then, as Teighan got older, I was simply feeding her too much of the wrong food.

“I gave her ready meals, and always the same size portions as myself and the other children. On top of that, she wasn’t getting enough exercise.”

Shane’s mother, Hayley, 27, a housewife from Barking, Essex, had also been in denial about her son’s size.

Although doctors had told her in no uncertain terms that Shane had to lose weight, they tested him for a range of conditions including diabetes and genetic anomalies, which only confirmed her view there was a medical reason for his weight gain.

It was only at the end of last year, with all tests having come back negative — and noticing that her other children, Louis, five, and Tayla, three, were also gaining weight — that Hayley was finally forced to face the truth.

“I knew deep down that I was probably doing something wrong, but I had no idea what. I’ve always been big myself — I’m a size 16 to 18 — and their father is big, too, so I kept telling myself that being big was in our genes.”

Prior to the fat camp, Professor Gatelyinterviewed the parents about their children’s diet, exercise levels and lifestyles.

Over the course of the initial weekend, parents were put through a detailed educational programme — including learning how to read labels, make child-appropriate meals and what exercise their children should be doing — while the youngsters participated in a range of physical activities.

The camp doesn’t promote fad diets or gimmicks, just advice about eating less and exercising more.

At the end of the weekend, the families were sent away with a six-week plan to follow at home, and received weekly phone calls during which they were offered support and advice.

Hayley admits that not only was most of the information a revelation, but until the course, she hadn’t fully grasped the ramifications of her children’s weight.

Although it was Shane’s weight that had initially spurred her to get involved, she discovered Louis had a BMI of 22.6 — well into the obese range — and Tayla was also classified as overweight.

“Professor Gately said that if an adult had a BMI as high as Shane’s, the chances of things such as diabetes, heart disease and cancer wouldn’t even be open for debate,” says Hayley.

“I was gobsmacked. When Professor Gately went on to say it was nothing to with their metabolism and all to do with the amount of food they were eating versus the energy they were expending , I burst into tears. I can’t even begin to describe how ashamed I felt.”

Since the beginning of the course, Shane’s weight has dropped to eight-and- a-half stone and he’s now wearing clothes for a nine-year-old.

Louis has also lost almost a stone.

Even I’ve lost half a stone,’ says their mum Hayley.

This has been achieved by simple style and diet changes.

Instead of pizza and chips or chicken nuggets, Hayley prepares healthy meals from scratch — such as grilled chicken with vegetables. The children start their day with cereal or wholegrain toast and fruit, have sandwiches instead of school dinners and snack on fruit.

“I’ve also mastered portion size,” saysHayley.

“I used to think that because Shane was a big boy, he needed big portions. Now I weigh everything and have invested in smaller bowls so they eat less.”

Before fat camp, the children had never been swimming. Now, Hayley takes them to the pool at least once a week and sends them out to play on their bikes instead of watching TV.

Most importantly, she has set strict boundaries when it comes to their behaviour.

“I’d fallen into the cycle of feeling guilty about their size and giving them sweets to show them how much I loved them,” she says.

“And when they were being naughty and arguing, I’d bribe them with crisps and chocolate.”

Parents’ willingness to give in to their children’s demands was a problem for the Yadid family from Bushey, Hertfordshire, also on the fat camp.

Janine Yadid, 37, runs a children’s nursery where she prepares meals every day, and although she knows all about a balanced diet, her hard work was being undermined by her engineer husband, Rami — he simply gave their children Edden, five, and Tal, two, crisps and sweets whenever they wanted.

Although not as extreme as the situation faced by Sonia and Hayley, Janine’s daughter Edden was classified as obese, and Tal was already officially overweight.

“Edden wears you down with her demands until you feel you have no choice but to give in to her,” says Janine.

“I was more strict than my husband.

“He’d prefer to give them chocolate and see them happy than say no and make them cry. I was making the mistake of letting them snack on nuts, thinking they were healthy. In fact, the calorie content of nuts was far too high, so they were gaining weight.”

With Professor Gately’s help, Janine realised she and her husband needed to work on their communication so that they agreed on their children’s diet.

She also needed to be stricter at mealtimes. Another issue identified was that the children were asking for seconds and so ended up having similar-sized meals to their parents.

“All we needed to do was tweak our regime,” says Janine.

“Although there were a few tears at first, the children adapted to the new routine fairly well.”

Six weeks after the course, Edden’s BMI has gone down by 1.5 points to 18, which means she is now officially overweight, not obese.

Meanwhile, in Scotland, Teighan is proudly showing off her new, more streamlined figure.

The improvement is dramatic. Before fat camp she weighed 6st 2lb; she now weighs 4st 11lb.

“The hardest thing was explaining we had to follow the new diet because she was overweight,” says Sonia.

“I’d always tried to protect her, and when her friends called her fat I’d say she was beautiful as she was. I felt guilty telling Teighan the truth and she was very tearful about it, but I reassured her we’d get there together.”

The most important change Sonia has made, she says, is learning how to read food labels and count calories.

Teighan now sticks to a strict 1,200 calories a day and exercises on a trampoline every day. She is much fitter and no longer suffers from breathlessness.

“We did have a few problems at first — Teighan threw temper tantrums at mealtimes when she saw the vegetables on her plate and noticed she had smaller portions than everyone else,” says Sonia.

“But things are better now, and Teighan knows what she’s allowed to eat. I knew we’d reached a turning point the other day when she refused a piece of chocolate from a neighbour and asked for an apple instead.

“Its a shame Teighan has had to become aware of such issues as weight, calories and diet at such a young age, but needs must. She’s much happier and loves running around with her friends. The best thing of all is that I can now pick her up, as any mother should be able to do with their five-year-old.”

Pupils shun Jamie Oliver’s healthy diet for junk food runs

Jamie Oliver

Alexandra Frean, Education Editor

Students are operating a black-market trade in food banned in schools, including burgers and chocolate, in a backlash against healthier canteen menus such as those espoused by the celebrity chef Jamie Oliver.

Newly installed healthy menus in school canteens and the removal of junk food from vending machines have created a gap in the market that students have been quick to fill. Some of the most sophisticated operations are taking place at business and enterprise schools.

The move to healthier meals in schools was prompted by Oliver’s crusade in 2005 against Turkey Twizzlers and other unhealthy foods.

The following year the Government published a report setting definitive nutritional standards for school lunches.

One young smuggling mastermind, when finally caught, said to his school’s headmaster unapologetically: “But we were only doing what you taught us in business studies, Sir.”

After a tip from a head teacher at a Dorset secondary who broke up a “seriously big smuggling operation” run by a schoolboy, The Times has uncovered several similar contraband schemes. The head, who did not want to identify his school, was convinced that the switch to a healthy menu and the policy of keeping pupils on the premises at lunchtime had created an opening for entrepreneurs.

He became suspicious when he noticed two 14-year-old boys approaching the school weighed down with Lidl carrier bags.

“The thin wiry creatures, in full uniform but with shortened ties, shirts hanging out, were walking a heavily laden bicycle. The bags were dripping off the bike’s handlebars, crossbars and saddle like a scene from some desperate endeavour on foot and mule to reach a lost city in the Peruvian mountains,” he said.

A teacher nicknamed Columbo tracked down the boys and their illicit cargo: 60 cans of fizzy drinks and piles of milk chocolate.

“We discovered they were just the buyers. Someone else had funded the purchase, a player who in turn was funded by unknowns, who were taking the lion’s share.

“Getting to the core of the operation was like peeling an onion, there appeared to be no centre,” the head added.

He suspects that similar operations are happening to a greater or lesser extent in most schools.

Sure enough, when The Times appealed to head teachers for similar tales, the response was rapid and clear.

“It has happened to us. Kids with motorbikes buying McDonald’s burgers in bulk and flogging them in the playground. We are a business and enterprise school in Essex so I guess I should not be surprised,” one said. “When challenged, the boy at the centre said he was just being enterprising.”

Another, this time from Wales, said: “The ‘McDonald’s run’, where sixth-formers with cars take orders for the lower school who are locked in at lunchtimes is one of the best bits of student enterprise I have seen for a long time.”

It is not just business studies teachers who have been giving children ideas; it is also the parents. Two mothers from Rotherham gained publicity for feeding burgers to their children through the school railings after the introduction of a healthy new menu.

Brian Lightman, president of the Association of School and College Leaders and head teacher at St Cyres School in Penarth, Vale of Glamorgan, said that the healthy eating initiative would only succeed if students were allowed a say.

“Because these changes have been imposed without allowing time for them to gain a sense of ownership, schools are reporting cases of students finding innovative ways around the new regulations,” he said. Of course, if today’s teenager crisp smugglers really want a good excuse when caught, they might be well advised to point to Jamie Oliver himself. As an enterprising 11-year-old he used to lease school-lockers from fellow pupils, from where he would sell sweets he had bought at the cash-and-carry.

Alternatively, students could also point to the teachers who regularly sneak out at lunch time for burgers and chips, now that they are no longer on the menu.

On and off the menu

— At least two portions of fruit and veg per day, per child. One of these should be salad or vegetables and one fruit — fresh, tinned or a fruit salad

— A dairy food must be available

— A non-dairy source of protein — meat, fish, eggs, nuts, pulses and non-green beans — must be available daily. Red meat must be available at least twice a week in primaries and three times in secondaries. Fish must be on offer once a week in primaries and twice in secondaries. Oily fish has to be available at least once every three weeks

— A starchy food, either bread, pasta, noodles, rice, potatoes, sweet potatoes, yams, millet or cornmeal, must be available daily

— All drinks are prohibited except for skimmed or semi-skimmed milk, pure fruit juices, yoghurt and milk drinks with less than 5 per cent added sugar, combinations of the above, low-calorie hot chocolate, tea and coffee

— Manufactured meat products must meet legal minimum meat content levels. They must not be economy burgers

— No table salt

— No more than two deep-fried items per week

— No sweets, chocolate or savoury snacks, apart from nuts and seeds

— Pupils must have access to free, fresh drinking water at all times

Source: Times Educational Supplement

Old Bailey opens its unseen files

Transcripts of 210,000 trials from across four centuries are now freely available online

This article appeared in the Observer on Sunday April 27 2008 on p21 of the News section.

Dr Crippen and Ethel le Neve at Bow St magistrates' court

Dr Crippen and Ethel le Neve during a remand hearing in London. Photograph: Science photo library

The long arm of the law now stretches across time: from tomorrow, the transcripts of every trial heard at the Old Bailey from 1674 to 1913 can be read online, free of charge. The records of more than 210,000 criminal trials held from shortly after the Great Fire of London until just before the Great War, and the biographical details of around 3,000 men and women executed at Tyburn, are to be posted on the Old Bailey Proceedings website (oldbaileyonline.org).

The cases include some of the most sensational in history, such as the trials in which Oscar Wilde was convicted of gross indecency and the infamous Dr Hawley Harvey Crippen, who killed his wife, was brought to justice.

‘People from all over the world can visit the site for free and get a valuable insight into a diverse range of crimes, from pickpocketing and robbery to abduction and murder,’ said Professor Robert Shoemaker, co-director of the project. ‘These crimes were committed by Irish terrorists, train robbers and suffragettes, as well as by ordinary people. Through these transcripts, we can read the personal accounts of events by the accused and the accusations of their prosecutors.’

The site is the largest single source of searchable information about everyday British lives and behaviour ever published, said co-director Professor Tim Hitchcock. ‘Besides the desperate drama of crimes punished, the proceedings give us a new and remarkable access to the everyday. History is full of information about kings and queens and wars, but there isn’t much that tells us about the everyday life of ordinary people.’

The website, published by the Humanities Research Institute, is a collaboration by the Universities of Sheffield and Hertfordshire and the Open University. Funded by the Arts and Humanities Research Council, the trials run to more than 110,000 pages of text and some 120 million words. In addition to the text of the trials, the website provides 195,000 digital images, as well as contemporary maps, images of the courtroom and information on the historical and legal background to the Old Bailey court.

‘Until now this treasure trove of social, legal and family history has only been available to a few dedicated historians, who were prepared to spend months peering at microfilms,’ said Hitchcock. ‘Now everyone from schoolchildren to amateur historians can have easy access to this wealth of information.’

The site also enables people to search for criminal ancestors. Joan Brewer, a researcher, found her husband’s great-great-grandmother, Phoebe Douglas, had been transported to Australia in 1829. Douglas’s trial details how she and two friends distracted the owner of an east London draper’s shop, allowing them to steal 30 yards of printed cotton, valued at 19 shillings.

Brewer said discovering the criminal history of her relative had made her proud of her heritage. ‘It was a huge surprise but wonderful to be able to read the transcript of Phoebe’s trial,’ she said. ‘Life for her was clearly very hard: her husband had been transported to Bermuda as a convict, then she was transported to Australia for what we would consider to be a very small crime in today’s society.

‘What made it even sadder was that she had a child she wasn’t able to bring with her to Australia,’ Brewer added. ‘Phoebe was a remarkable lady, one we are proud to have in our family history.’